The WP-Members User List plugin gives you a shortcode that you can use to display lists of users on your site. Default parameters can be set in the plugin settings, but custom list parameters can be passed through the shortcode which allows you to set up multiple lists with different parameters.
The User List plugin allows you to create user directories and lists that can be used in a variety of different ways. It can be used for searchable user directories but it can also be used to display groups of users for other purposes. It is initiated by shortcode and each shortcode instance can have different settings, so you are not limited to just the defaults that you create in the plugin’s settings. There is a (very) basic demo on the WP-Members Demo Site.
The output is also very flexible when using CSS. The demo also has some list instances that have completely custom output (the descriptions of how to implement those customizations are available on the support site).
Note that you do need to have WP-Members installed and activated, but you do not need to be using content restriction.
Plugin InfoCurrent Stable Version: 1.9.4
Minimum WordPress Version: 3.6
Tested up to WordPress Version: 4.9